A 940-page, all-human Riemann proof took 12 years. AI helped flag problems in 8 hours
First seen on X 2 days ago@leanprover ♥ 21,34822 views
"It is all human, with no AI." Stanford professor and American Mathematical Society president Ravi Vakil posted that on Nov. 20, hours after Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge said he had proved the Riemann hypothesis with Claude. Just before a board meeting, Vakil rushed out Alessandro Masullo's 940-page draft proof of the generalized Riemann hypothesis, roughly 12 years in the making.
Masullo had planned to spend another year polishing it with Stanford number theorist Brian Conrad, who had quietly reviewed it for months, The Decoder reported. About eight hours after posting, Vakil added that "several people have contacted me to report problems in the proposed proof, identified with the assistance of different AI models," and said he makes no claim about the proof strategy.
Claude's proof got the opposite verdict. In a joint statement on Nov. 21, the Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative wrote: "We hereby certify that both the statement and the proof of the Riemann Hypothesis are correct." Dozens of people compiled the 17-million-line Lean library without errors, and comparator checks confirmed the theorem matches Mathlib's existing statement, Unite.AI reported. Lean's post drew 21,000 likes.
The open question is whether humans can understand it. Alpöge has released only a four-page note and the code, which he says would run past 250,000 pages written out. Hugging Face co-founder Thomas Wolf said he would love to read the trace of Alpöge's dialogue with Claude.
Comments 0
Select a sentence in the story (long-press on phones) to comment on it.
“The Lean FRO and Mathlib Initiative have released a joint statement on the Lean verification of the Riemann Hypothesis.”
